Butt Witch’s New Toys

Note: This story was written with assistance by https://talktotransformer.com/  I provided prompts and edited the results to make sense, creating something resembling a full story. Enjoy.



“That’s a good little slut,” Butt Witch said as she pressed Reggie’s face between her ass cheeks. “Lick my asshole nice and good, and I’ll give you a reward!”

Reggie did as she commanded, licking up and down the asshole. Her tongue seemed to be the key to unlocking the inner workings of the hole. She let out a satisfied grunt, feeling her asshole contract around Reggie’s tongue. As her tongue went deeper, she also pushed deeper into her rectum. The sound of her tongue moving on the inside of Butt Witch’s anal cavity and the feel of it against the walls of her rectum brought a feeling of warmth and pleasure to her core.

“Oh fuck yes,” Reggie moaned as she slid her tongue down into her asshole. She looked over at the others and saw them in a similar situation. Esther was all on her hands and knees now with her tongue in Todd’s ass.

Breathing heavily with her eyes wide open, Butt Witch looked up at the ceiling of her small, dark room, still drenched in sweat. She could not help but notice how much more attractive Reggie looked, now that she was rimming her asshole.

“Now it’s time to take off my panties,” Esther said. She sat on the bed, and spread her legs. Todd quickly got his clothes off. “What are you waiting for?” Esther said.

Todd was already on his knees behind her and reached out with his tongue. His fingers touched her pussy. “Ah, fuck yes,” she moaned. Butt Witch was standing beside her, watching their action while Reggie worshipped her ass.

“You like that? You like getting rimmed while watching us?” Esther asked, but the Butt Witch only grinned at her.

Todd moaned and rubbed his crotch against Esther’s. “Yes, yes,” he gasped. “Fuck, yes,” he gasped again. “Ohhh, yeah, I want more, I want to do it right here in front of you!”

Esther took his hands and put them under her waist and grabbed her curly black hair. His arms held her steady. She started to move his hands from her waist down to her ass.

“Ohhhhh, yes! Yes! Yes, oh, yes, yes, yes, yes!”

He took her hands and led her slowly, and carefully, over the edge. Esther could feel his dick growing stiff, and her pussy was beginning to spasm. She gripped his hands and pushed them down. Her hips were shaking, and she was panting.

“I’m not ready, baby,” he said. “But don’t worry. Just let me finish in your little pussy.”

He began thrusting into her as she wrapped her legs around his waist and held him close. His thick cock slid inside her, and he began to fill her from head to toe. Esther bit down on her lip as she felt the cum seep through her vagina, and feel the thick stream of semen erupt from her pussy. The warm liquid dripped over her belly as she gasped for breath. She leaned forward, lifting her ass off of the bed and her bottom from the bed sheets.

The Butt Witch smiled widely, saying, “That was quite the show, you two! Now, as for you…”

She pulled Reggie’s face away from her generous ass and threw her on top of Esther, so their pussies were touching. Bending down between their legs, her snakelike tongue began licking up and down.

Overwhelmed by the other woman, Reggie was lost in pleasure. Esther gave a few gentle whines that couldn’t even be mistaken for cries. It was obvious that she had never experienced such bliss.

“Ahh…! … Ahh…!”

“Yes, yes. That was really great. …Ah, yes… I want to do this again, but before that… I want to take off this shirt, you see…”

The Butt Witch smiled widely as she pulled her shirt away. She revealed her beautiful figure, a small smile forming on her lips as the girls admired her body. Her green skin glistened with sweat, and her white hair was swaying in the wind.

“My precious sluts… You’re both very cute, you know. Just look at your tiny bodies,” she said with a giggle. She groped Reggie’s ass with one hand, and was stroking Esther’s pussy with a finger.

Using her body transformation powers, the Butt Witch grew a large, throbbing green dick where her pussy had been moments before. Reggie looked back over her shoulder, eyes wide at the sight of the emerald phallus.

“You… you want to put that inside us?” she asked, incredulous.

“Maybe this is the first time a big cock has touched a tight pussy. Or I can use your mouth. Oh, my god, the pleasure! That’s it… Maybe your tight asshole… You look so sweet and innocent, but I can tell you want a real dick up there. Look how wet it is… You really like that?”

She stroked Esther’s asshole, and Reggie’s asshole as well, when Reggie cried out, “Oh, my god, you’re a fucking animal. Just get it in already! You know you like it when I tell you to fuck my ass.”

The Butt Witch slid her cock into Reggie’s ass, and it was tight enough to be painful, but Reggie loved it. Butt Witch was big, but she was so happy to have her inside her ass.

Esther wriggled underneath her friend while Butt Witch fucked her. She whined needily, “My turn! My turn!”

Meanwhile, Todd crawled back over to the group. He got down behind Butt Witch’s thrusting hips and spread her ass, sticking his tongue in where Reggie’s had been moments before.

Reggie felt Butt Witch’s cock push inside her again and again, and then it was all she could do to keep from crying out in pleasure.

Esther’s cunt was dripping with her juices, and her juices were all over Reggie, too. Reggie reached down between her legs and was able to get her fingers deep inside her friend’s pussy.

The wetness of Esther’s pussy made Reggie wetter still, and the look on her face made her even wetter. She couldn’t believe what she was seeing, how Esther moaned lustfully. It was amazing.

“Oh Reggie, you’re so fucking horny right now! Butt Witch, I need you to take your cock out of her ass, and fuck me so hard,” Esther said.

The Butt Witch obliged, leaving Reggie’s asshole gaping and empty, and plunged her cock into Esther. The wetness in her pussy made her body ache as she fucked her pussy. She was ready to cum, and she was ready to fill Esther’s wet, tight pussy with her cum.

“Fuck, oh fuck, you’re so fucking sexy,” Esther said, as she rode the rhythm of her wet pussy, her eyes looking up into Reggie’s eyes, watching her pant and moan while the Butt Witch rammed her pussy.

Suddenly, Esther’s pussy was full of the warm, thick cum. Reggie could feel her body tensing up, beneath her, tightening and contracting with the cum filling her pussy. Reggie could feel the warmth and wetness in her cunt and around her friend was pumped full of the Butt Witch’s cum. Grinding her pussy against her, she also came.

“Ahhhhhhhhhhh!” Esther moaned, her body trembling. She was covered in Reggie’s cum, her own cum, and Butt Witch’s cum. Reggie had cum on her own friend, and Esther’s pussy was also filled with the Butt Witch’s cum. Esther felt as though her cunt was burning. She moaned, and Reggie, too, could feel her pussy twitching and convulsing as she continued to squirt all over her. Reggie’s ass, however, was empty. Her ass was empty.

“Ugh…” Esther grunted, her legs weak. She felt the hot cum covering her pussy, and she felt it seeping from between her thighs. She felt her crotch wet with the juices of the ass-eater. She felt the hot, thick cum oozing from her cunt. She felt the cum seeping out of her cunt and running down her thighs. She felt the cum leaking out of her pussy and drip down the crack of her ass, and she felt it dripping down the inside of her thighs, and it dripped out of her pussy and onto the floor.

“Ngh!” she groaned. She heard a muffled scream, and her eyes fluttered shut. Esther felt something warm and soft press against her thighs. She felt someone’s hand touch the soft spot of her vagina, and her eyes shot open, looking down. Her nipples were erect, as she gazed down at the person who’d been inside of her. She couldn’t believe what she saw. Butt Witch was so turned on that her entire body was tense. Her cock was hard, even as the cum from her previous orgasm dripped from the tip.

It felt like her pussy was burning, and she couldn’t stop thinking about it. “I’m so wet! I didn’t realize…” She couldn’t think, and she was so turned on that she couldn’t focus. “Can you help me?”

Esther felt the soft hand of Reggie stroke across her soft breasts, and a second hand slid between her legs. The fingers stumbled across her slit, and her moans grew louder and louder as they slipped in. The fingers dug into her, and the warmth ran through her pussy.

“Yes,” Reggie said. His hand slid into her again. “You are wet, your cunt is dripping. You like this, don’t you?” He pushed into her, and she was wondering if she was going to use more of her fingers or just one, but the fingers dug into her, and her tongue licked one of Esther’s stiff nipples. “You have never had anything like this.”

Reggie reached up and touched her hair, and her mouth opened and closed as she felt her up, her hand sliding back and forth between them. Reggie pressed her fingers into her cunt, and she wanted to scream, but she didn’t dare to move, didn’t dare try to get away. She was still cumdrunk and her fingers were still pushing in and out of her, still stretching her. Her mouth parted to get air, and her body was jerking with each movement. Reggie pressed into her, and she felt her cunt squeezing her.

Meanwhile, the Butt Witch decided to use Todd to get her second orgasm. Pulling his face out of her ass, she turned and let her big green cock slap onto his purple face. The boy cried out as he felt the thick cock rub across his face. Todd grabbed onto her hips and tried to get free. She continued to slap his face with her big green cock. She let out a small moan as he started to lick it.

As the boy licked her cock, he looked over his shoulder and looked at the two girls on the bed. “Damn, you’re both so hot!” he said in a hushed tone. Todd noticed the two girls’ lusty expressions, as well as their heavy breathing.

“You two look so good together!” he said.

“Yeah! You like it, huh?” the Butt Witch asked, smiling.

“Yes,” he whispered.

“So do I,” she said as she pushed her cock into his mouth. She sighed as he started thrusting, feeling the warmth of his mouth. “Mmmmm,” she moaned.

Todd gagged as she began thrusting into his face. “Yeah, that’s good, baby,” she murmured. “I think I’m getting close to cumming.”

Todd started to jerk himself off as she grabbed his head and began fucking his face. “Ooooooooh,” she groaned. “So much cum, baby. That feels so good. I’m gonna cum so fucking hard, baby.”

He came so hard that it hurt a little, splashing his jizz onto the floor, but that only made her want more. “Swallow it all,” she whispered as she pushed her throbbing cock into his mouth. “Just for me.”

He did as he was told. She pulled out, and then pushed it back in again. “I’m cumming so much! Drink it all, baby,” she said, and started to cum again.

She came so hard that her cock pulsed. Her cum was hot, sticky, and just like he wanted. She had her orgasm. She could feel herself starting to come down. She couldn’t wait. Her cock was already hard again.

Butt Witch looked over at the two girls grinding against each other on the bed. Reggie and Esther panted and moaned, grinding their pussies together.

“I’m so wet!” Reggie moaned, “Ohh! Ohhh!”

“Ohhh,” Esther moaned. “That’s good,” she murmured.

Reggie’s voice got louder. “Oh, shit! Ohhh! Oh!” she moaned, “This is so fucking good!”

Esther felt her nipples begin to harden as her hand moved away from Reggie’s pussy. Reggie’s body began to shake and convulse, her hips moving in time with her breaths, her body moving up and down. She stopped suddenly, however, as Butt Witch’s hand cracked down on her ass with a loud smack.

“Don’t think I’m done with you sluts just yet,” Butt Witch said with an evil grin.

“No,” Esther said to her, as she continued to writhe on the bed, her hand still on Reggie’s pussy. “Please,” she begged, “please don’t do this.”

As if in response to Esther’s plea, a green hand appeared in the air, pressing against her cunt with force. Esther screamed in pain and frustration as the fingers went deeper. She began to writhe, her breasts swinging with each movement. The fingers moved in a pattern, as if to guide her to another orgasm. The fingers had penetrated so deeply, they were now working inside her cunt. The fingers moved up and down, the pressure getting more intense, and Esther’s legs shook. She could feel the hot, slippery flesh of her cunt rubbing against the fingers.

Before she could cum, however, the fingers disappeared. Suddenly, Reggie yelped, as Butt Witch slid her green digits into her ass.

“I still need to fill this tight little ass with my seed,” Butt Witch said with a chuckle.

“Please, can I have more?” Reggie asked.

“Just a bit,” Butt Witch answered. “The best is always up to you.”

Reggie’s eyes widened in surprise. “Really?” she asked.

“Yeah,” she answered. “As much as I love that little hole, I’d have a hard time cumming from just fingering it.”

“Thank you,” she answered with a small laugh.

“I’ll even let you cum,” she added with a wink. “Just not from my fingers.”

Reggie’s eyes widened as Butt Witch pressed her cock against her asshole. With a grunt, the cock slid inside and once again Reggie’s ass was full. Underneath her, Esther whined and wriggled in frustration from her denied orgasm.

Inch by inch, the dick pushed in and Reggie let out a groan. With a few thrusts, the cock slipped into Reggie’s ass and Reggie felt the pain and pleasure of being filled up. It was so good.

Esther’s body was writhing underneath her, and Reggie’s eyes were rolling up in her head from the pleasure of Butt Witch’s cock. Butt Witch grabbed her hips with both hands and began thrusting wildly.

“This ass belongs to me, now!” Butt Witch cried gleefully. “All of your asses do!”

“Yes! Yes, this ass is yours!” Reggie screamed. “Fuck it as much as you please!”

With each thrust, Reggie felt Butt Witch’s balls slap her cheeks. Her pussy throbbed, and Reggie’s body tensed up, as she felt Esther slide her fingers inside. Esther had one hand in Reggie’s pussy, and one hand in her own, fingering them both while Butt Witch fucked Reggie’s ass. Reggie didn’t have to think, she knew. She just knew.

Her ass felt like it was being stretched by a hundred hands as Butt Witch fucked her. Reggie gasped for breath as Esther came underneath her, and her body was writhing. She looked down at Esther’s body, and she could see the waves of semen still leaking from her pussy. Esther’s fingers pulled out of her pussy. Esther had one hand in Reggie’s pussy, the other moved to her mouth. Reggie felt her mouth open as Esther’s fingers slid inside. Her ass throbbed, and she tasted Esther’s orgasm.

She licked her fingers and she swallowed. Reggie felt her pussy pulsate as Esther rubbed her clit with her other hand. Reggie felt herself cum, drenching Esther’s fingers with her juices.

“Naughty girls, cumming without permission,” Butt Witch said. She spanked Reggie again, punishing her. “In the future you’ll cum when I tell you to!”

“Yes, ma’am!” Reggie cried out, her asshole stretched as Butt Witch increased her pace.

The Butt Witch started to cackle and laugh, but Reggie only smiled, she was glad to feel Esther’s hand on her clit, pressing her fingers against her clit, the fingers of her left hand moving against her cunt, fingers of her right hand rubbing her clit.

“Yes, I’ve been here for hours, I need a release,” Reggie said. “I love you, Esther‼ I love you, I love you so much‼ I need a release!”

“You’re such a needy slut,” Butt Witch admonished. However, she was about to cum for the third time in a row. “Here, take this!”

Butt Witch came inside Reggie’s ass. Reggie cried out, “Yes! Yes! Fill my ass with your cum!”

She came hard and again and again. Reggie felt as though her insides were being stretched open. After a moment, Butt Witch pulled her cock from her ass and let the semen pour out onto the bed.

“What about me?” Esther asked, still needing another orgasm. Butt Witch tossed Reggie a strapon.

“Use that to make your friend cum,” Butt Witch said. “I’m going to cum inside Todd’s ass, now.”

Todd shook his head. “‬I didn’t sign up for this!”

He reached down, grabbed his cock, and jerked it back and forth, trying to get his thoughts in order.

“Butt Witch,” he said. ‬”I’m not doing this.”

And then he heard a clicking noise and felt himself get hard again. Reggie had put on the strapon and was about to enter Esther’s pussy.

“I’m going to cum inside your ass,” Butt Witch whispered. “I have the power to do it, and you have the power to say no, but none of you are going to stop me.”

”No, I’m not saying no,” Todd said, ”but I don’t think you are going to.”

”What? Why? Do you not want to lose your ass? You have seen how I fuck them,” Butt Witch said. ”Look at how hard I make my cock,” she continued. ”What do you have to lose? You see, I can give you all I want, and your ass is going to be so happy.”

She pushed Todd onto all fours and positioned her cock against his purple asshole. She began to slide it in slowly. He groaned as his asshole was stretched, and soon her whole cock was inside him.

“You like that,” she asked, but Todd was so focused on the fucking she was doing to him, he had no idea what she was asking. So, she fucked him.

The fucking continued to go on for a while, but eventually she couldn’t take it any more. She pulled out of Todd’s ass.

”Fuck,” she said. ”That’s what you get when you fuck with me! I just fucked your ass,” she said. ”And now I have to go fuck it again!”

”Well,” he said, ”you know what? You can have it again.”

”You want me to fuck it again?” Butt Witch said, laughing. ”I’ll fucking give it to you.”

As they fucked again, it was clear that Butt Witch wasn’t trying to make fun of him; she was just having fun. Her cock slammed into his ass over and over, her heavy green balls bouncing against his smaller purple ones. As she fucked him, he watches his two best friends fucking on the bed. Reggie held Esther’s feet in the air as she plowed her with the strapon. His cock was rock hard.

Butt Witch groped his ass cheeks while she fucked him. His cock rocked back and forth under him with each thrust. She laughed evilly.

“I’m going to get used to this!” She said. “Three teen asses for me to fuck all I want!”

“You mean…this isn’t a dream?!” he asked in a panicked tone.

She rolled her eyes. “It’s my world, and my rules, and I’ll do whatever I want!”

“But what about us?” he said, struggling to keep control of his own body.

She held his head as she thrust into him, pushing down on it until it was all the way on the floor. She stood over him, cock pumping into his ass with force.

“You’re going to cum!” she yelled in pleasure. ‬”Cum!”‬

He gasped and he let loose a big load, splattering the floor with his seed for the second time.

“Thank you for being so good,” she said. “You can be my fucktoy.”

“Thank you,” he whispered, his eyes closed as he started to drift in and out of sleep.

After Reggie had fucked Esther, and Esther had fucked Reggie, the two of them lay back and felt the wetness of the other’s ass as it touched their own.

They got into an even more intimate position than before. Butt Witch’s hands were behind Esther’s knees, and Esther took Butt Witch’s cock in her mouth and sucked it.

“What are you doing?” Butt Witch asked.

“I have no idea. It just felt so right.”

While Esther sucked her cock, Reggie moved behind Butt Witch and began licking her ass once again.

“Going back to your new home, butt-slut?” Butt Witch asked. “You’re going to spend a lot of time back there from now on.”

As the day progressed, Reggie continued her licking, while Esther continued her sucking, and Butt Witch continued to fuck Todd’s ass, and the room was filled with noises of sex.

As Esther was blowing Todd, Butt Witch was moaning her approval while his cock was in her mouth. As the smell of sex wafted through the room, a few things came into Butt Witch’s head.

A few things she wanted to do.

She felt her balls getting heavier.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.